Philippine Air Lines Flight 345: Loss of Control near Cebu, 1967
On the evening of 28 February 1967, a Philippine Air Lines Fokker F27 Friendship was close to the end of a domestic flight from Manila to Cebu. A few miles from the runway, the aircraft pitched sharply nose-up and then lost control. It came down just short of the airfield. Of the 19 people on board, 12 died and 7 survived.
At a glance
| Date | 28 February 1967 |
| Aircraft | Fokker F27 Friendship 100, registration PI-C501 |
| Route | Manila International Airport to Mactan–Cebu International Airport |
| People on board | 19 (15 passengers, 4 crew) |
| Fatalities | 12 |
| Survivors | 7 |
| Site | Basak, Lapu-Lapu City, about 0.75 nautical miles from the threshold of runway 04 |
| Investigation | Aircraft Accident Investigation Board of the Philippines, report dated April 1967 |
Summary
The aircraft was on a visual and radio-beacon approach to runway 04 in fine weather. It pitched up at about 1,500 ft, and the crew applied full power. Passengers were then asked to move forward to shift the load. Before that could be completed, the aircraft rolled left and right, sank in a tail-low attitude and struck the ground short of the runway. The Board gave loss of control at low altitude as the probable cause. It named a load distribution that put the centre of gravity behind its rear limit as a contributing factor.
Background: the aircraft and crew
The F27 is a twin-engine turboprop, a type widely used on short domestic routes. PI-C501 was built in 1960. By the time of the accident it had logged nearly 16,000 flight hours across more than 10,000 flights. Its airworthiness certificate was valid until April 1967.
The Board looked at the maintenance record for the previous six months. During that time the aircraft had been replaced by other aircraft on 72 scheduled flights because of defects, some of them recurring. The rate-of-climb indicator had been replaced 17 times and the airspeed indicator 16 times. Vibration, from mild to severe, had been reported on 12 occasions. The investigators concluded that none of these problems contributed to the accident.
The captain was 35 years old. He held a current airline pilot's licence with ratings for the F27 and the DC-3. He had flown about 8,000 hours, 1,180 of them on the F27, and had no previous accident or incident. The co-pilot was 24 and held a current commercial licence with the same type ratings. He had about 1,758 hours, including 1,116 on the F27. Both had medical certificates with no waivers or limitations.
The flight
Flight 345 left Manila at 17:20 Philippine time (09:20 UTC). It was cleared under instrument flight rules, meaning it was to be flown by reference to instruments and air traffic control. The route followed the Amber 1 airway at 13,000 ft towards Mactan.
At 19:08 the crew reported descending through 6,000 ft and asked for a visual descent to 3,000 ft. About five minutes later they said they were starting a VOR approach to runway 04. A VOR is a ground radio beacon that gives pilots a bearing to follow. At 19:17 Mactan Approach cleared the flight to land. That was the last message from the aircraft.
About 3.5 nautical miles from the runway threshold, at about 1,500 ft, the aircraft pitched abruptly nose-up, and full throttle was applied. A crew member left the cockpit and asked some people to move to the front of the cabin. This was an attempt to bring the load forward and balance the aircraft. Moments later another crew member asked everyone to move forward. Before that was done, the aircraft began to roll from side to side and then descended in a tail-low attitude.
The left wing struck a coconut tree and some banana trees, and then the ground. The left propeller also hit the ground and separated from its engine. The aircraft nosed over and slid on its back. A fire then destroyed the fuselage. Emergency services and fire engines reached the scene 25 minutes after the accident.
The investigation
The wreckage lay across an area about 80 ft in diameter. The investigators found no damage that pre-dated the impact and no sign of an engine or airframe malfunction. The flaps, the hinged surfaces on the wings used at low speed, were retracted. The elevator trim tab was found in the full nose-down position. This is a small movable surface that helps hold the aircraft's pitch.
The Board established that the crew were properly licensed, that the aircraft had been regularly maintained, and that the weather was good. It gave the probable cause as loss of control at low altitude. It found that the load had been distributed badly. The centre of gravity, the point at which an aircraft balances, lay behind the rear limit set for the type. An aircraft loaded this way is more sensitive in pitch and harder to control, especially at low speed and low height. The Board treated this as a contributing factor.
The effort to shift passengers forward during the final approach fits that finding. The crew appear to have recognised a balance problem in the air and tried to correct it by moving weight. There was little height and time available in which to do so.
Legacy
The accident belongs to a long line of cases showing why weight and balance matter. How cargo, baggage and passengers are distributed affects handling as much as total weight does. The centre of gravity has to stay within published limits for the whole flight, including the approach, when speed is low and there is least height in which to recover.
The records available for this accident do not list individual safety recommendations or later regulatory changes. What the case shows is how a single loading error can overcome a well-maintained aircraft, a qualified crew and good weather. Modern airline practice still builds on that principle, through formal load sheets, loading checks and a clear record of where weight has been placed.

